IRMAA appeal or new determination: which to ask for
In short: most IRMAA problems are fixed with a "new initial determination", not an appeal. Use an appeal (Form SSA-561) only when none of the routes below fits. You have 60 days from your notice.
| Your situation | Ask for | Bring |
|---|---|---|
| Retirement, marriage, divorce, a spouse's death or another life-changing event | New determination (Form SSA-44) | Proof of the event and your newer income. SSA-44 helper |
| You amended the tax return Social Security used | New determination | Amended return plus the IRS receipt letter or a transcript |
| The IRS figure is wrong | IRS correction first, then a new determination | The IRS letter showing the correction (IRS: 1-800-829-1040) |
| Social Security used your return from three years back | New determination | A signed copy of the more recent return |
| Married filing separately, but you lived apart all year | New determination | Your signed statement that you lived apart |
| None of the above | Appeal (reconsideration) | Form SSA-561 and any evidence |
You can ask for both at once. A Roth conversion or a big capital gain will not qualify for either.
Deadlines
- Appeal: 60 days from when you received the notice (assumed 5 days after its date).
- Life-changing event: any time after the event and the drop in income.
- Amended return: within three years after the end of the tax year it amends.
- Lived apart all year: by the end of that premium year.
Missed the 60 days because Social Security steered you to a new determination that was then denied? That counts as good cause, so you can still appeal.
Appeal questions
How do I appeal IRMAA?
Send Form SSA-561 (Request for Reconsideration) to Social Security within 60 days of your notice. If that fails, you can ask for a hearing with a Medicare judge, then the Medicare Appeals Council, then federal court.
My appeal was denied. What now?
You can request a hearing (form HA-501). If the reason was a Roth conversion or a capital gain, the result is unlikely to change, because the law only allows newer years for listed life-changing events.
How we got these numbers
- Routes: POMS HI 01120.001; amended returns HI 01120.045; IRS corrections HI 01120.050; three-year-old data HI 01120.055; lived apart HI 01120.060.
- Appeals: POMS HI 01140.001 (60 days, appeal levels, hearings at the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals) and HI 01140.005 (good cause after a denied new determination).
- A "predetermination" notice of planned action is not a decision and has no appeal rights; ask for a new determination instead.