Independent site, not affiliated with any government agency. Figures come from CMS and SSA publications, cited on each page.

IRMAA appeal or new determination: which to ask for

In short: most IRMAA problems are fixed with a "new initial determination", not an appeal. Use an appeal (Form SSA-561) only when none of the routes below fits. You have 60 days from your notice.

What to ask for
Your situationAsk forBring
Retirement, marriage, divorce, a spouse's death or another life-changing eventNew determination (Form SSA-44)Proof of the event and your newer income. SSA-44 helper
You amended the tax return Social Security usedNew determinationAmended return plus the IRS receipt letter or a transcript
The IRS figure is wrongIRS correction first, then a new determinationThe IRS letter showing the correction (IRS: 1-800-829-1040)
Social Security used your return from three years backNew determinationA signed copy of the more recent return
Married filing separately, but you lived apart all yearNew determinationYour signed statement that you lived apart
None of the aboveAppeal (reconsideration)Form SSA-561 and any evidence

You can ask for both at once. A Roth conversion or a big capital gain will not qualify for either.

Deadlines

  • Appeal: 60 days from when you received the notice (assumed 5 days after its date).
  • Life-changing event: any time after the event and the drop in income.
  • Amended return: within three years after the end of the tax year it amends.
  • Lived apart all year: by the end of that premium year.

Missed the 60 days because Social Security steered you to a new determination that was then denied? That counts as good cause, so you can still appeal.

Appeal questions

How do I appeal IRMAA?

Send Form SSA-561 (Request for Reconsideration) to Social Security within 60 days of your notice. If that fails, you can ask for a hearing with a Medicare judge, then the Medicare Appeals Council, then federal court.

My appeal was denied. What now?

You can request a hearing (form HA-501). If the reason was a Roth conversion or a capital gain, the result is unlikely to change, because the law only allows newer years for listed life-changing events.

How we got these numbers